The Middlebury Story
Welcome to Middlebury Hearth!
In the historic Marble Works district.
The Marble Works once processed marble and other rock from Brandon, Vermont. Many historic buildings in the area, such as St. Mary’s Church which was completed in 1903, were built incorporating this local marble and are still standing. In fact, the Marble Works themselves were erected with scrap marble accumulated during the processing! Today, the Marble Works hosts many Vermont-owned businesses and is a hub of activity in downtown Middlebury.
Reservations
Middlebury Menu
Salad
Flatbread
Specials
Desserts
Drinks
Evolution Salad 9
Local mixed greens tossed with organic carrots, organic celery, pickled red cabbage, carrots, toasted sesame seeds, fresh ginger-tamari vinaigrette made with housemade raspberry vinegar
Add-Ons
Community Bowl 34
Large bowl of our house salad, serves 4-5
Add-Ons
For the Kiddos 2
small bowl of shredded organic carrots with our evolution dressing
Our crust is 100% organic wheat milled into white flour with restored wheat germ, filtered water, kosher salt and fresh yeast. our cheeses are fine whole & buffalo milk mozzarella blend and Italian Grana Padano
One regular flatbread serves two to three people.
Can’t decide? Half & half regular sized breads available at no extra charge. Add $1.00 for small and gluten-free
Gluten-free crust from West Meadow Farm Bakery, one size only. Add $5.50 to the price of a small flatbread
Dancing Heart Small 12.00 Regular 16.00
Organic garlic oil, Grana Padano cheese, toasted sesame seeds, kosher salt & cracked black pepper
Cheese & Herb Small 13.00 Regular 17.00
Organic garlic oil, fine whole milk mozzarella, Italian Grana Padano cheese, fresh herbs
Med Bread Small 14.00 Regular 18.00
House made organic tomato sauce, fine whole milk mozzarella, Italian Grana Padano cheese, fresh herbs
New Vermont Sausage Small 18.00 Regular 25.00
House made nitrate-free maple fennel sausage with Duclos & Thompson pork, sundried tomatoes, caramelized onions, mushrooms, fine whole milk mozzarella, Italian Grana Padano cheese, fresh herbs
Revolution Small 16.00 Regular 22.00
Organic tomato sauce, caramelized onions, mushrooms, fine whole milk mozzarella, Italian grana padano cheese, fresh herbs
Punctuated Equilibrium Small 16.00 Regular 23.00
Kalamata olives, oven-roasted sweet red peppers, handmade Vermont goat cheese, fresh rosemary, red onions, fine whole milk mozzarella, italian grana padano cheese, fresh herbs
Pepperoni & Peppers Small 17.00 Regular 24.00
All natural nitrate-free pepperoni, green peppers, organic red onions, organic tomato sauce, fine whole milk mozzarella, Italian grana padano cheese, fresh herbs
Follow Your Bliss small 17 Regular 24
cauliflower or chicken, buffalo sauce, red onion, bayley hazen bleu cheese, mozzarella, fresh celery & carrots, house ranch drizzle
Apple, Bacon, Cheddar Small 17.00 Regular 24.00
Local oven roasted apples, Duclos & Thompson farm bacon, local cheddar, local maple syrup drizzle
Free Form Flatbread Small Sauce / Small (no sauce) 14.00 / 13.00 Regular Sauce / Regular (no sauce) 18.00 / 17.00
Any combination of anything!
Start with our Cheese & Herb or Medicine Wheel Flatbread & add your favorite toppings from the following list: caramelized onions, mushrooms, kalamata olives, sundried tomatoes, green peppers, red onions, Vermont goat cheese, extra mozzarella, vermont blue cheese, roasted red peppers, house made maple fennel sausage, nitrate free pepperoni
Add-Ons
Half & Half -
Half & Half regular-sized breads available $2 chargeordd $1 for small and gluten free
Gluten Free 6.00
Gluten-free crust from Hillside Lane Farm. This crust is gluten-free and vegan. One size only. Add $6.00 to the price of a small flatbread
Weekly Specials Soup $6 / Appetizer $8 / Special Flatbread $25-$26 / Dessert $7
Specials at Middlebury Hearth
April 15, 2025
Soup $6
Cream of spinach^
Appetizer $8
Blood orange^ and watermelon radish* salad
Flatbread
Carné $26
Lucas Family Farms beef*, purple and Yukon gold potatoes*, rainbow carrots*, and Jasper Hill’s Vault 5 cheddar*
Vegetarian $25
Blue house mushrooms*, caramelized purple top turnips*, white beans, leeks^, and Gruyere cheese
Dessert $7
Ledge Hill Farm duck egg* lemon meringue pie
* Local
^ Organic
Chocolate, Chocolate Chip Brownie Sundae 10.00
Served with two scoops of local ice cream and house made salted caramel sauce
Seasonal Crisp 8.00
local, seasonal fruit crisp with buttery oat topping
make it à la mode with our house-made gelato or sorbet add $3
House made Maple Lemonade 9 oz 4.00 16 oz 5.00
Ginger Brew (Maine Root) 5.00
Cane Sugar Soda (Boylan), cola, diet cola, ginger ale, lemon lime 5.00
Sparkling Water (Saratoga) 5.00
Q Club Soda 4
Cranberry Juice 9oz 3.00 16oz 4.00
Beer & Cider Market
We have a rotating draft selection of beers and ciders with something for every taste and curiosity.
We also carry many local ciders and beers in cans.
Wines Market
We have a rotating assortment of wines by the glass, half-carafe or bottle.
Coffee (med roast or decaf) 3.00
Iced Tea 4.00
Rookies Root Beer (on draft!) 9oz 4.00 16oz 5.00
Middlebury Gallery
Benefit Bakes
Being a good neighbor is part of American Flatbread’s mission. We wouldn’t be here today without the strength and support of our community. As a way of giving back, we host weekly Benefit Bakes where we donate a portion of every flatbread sold to an organization working to improve our community. These evenings are dedicated not only to raising funds but to raising awareness around community issues and individuals.
GOOD FOOD HELPS
If you have a local organization that you would like to raise awareness for and would like more information on our Benefit Bakes, please email us using the link below.
Join the Middlebury American Flatbread Team
American Flatbread is always accepting employment inquiries from enthusiastic and passionate people to share in our philosophies of serving real food, supporting local farms, as well as giving back to the community. If you are ready to work in an environment that supports you and the work we’ll be doing together, then apply today! We are currently bolstering our leadership team. If you have an interest in growing with us while using your creativity and critical thinking, we offer competitive pay and a good benefits package that supports the health and well-being of our staff.